SJS SJS Referee report Form

Version beta 01. If you prefer you are welcome to do download and submit the referee report form by e-mail to southbchem@gmail.com.

Referee name: First Last
Please type your complete name.
Insitution:

Where do you work?
E-mail

What is your e-mai?
E-mail confirmation

Please, confirm your e-mail.
WhatsApp or Telegram - (###) - ### ####
Please include your telephone number here
Institutional referre curricular webpage:

Please, type the URL of yourself in your institution (mandatory).
Section Break
Title of the manuscript

Please type the manuscript title here.
Section Break
1- Is the subject matter suitable for publication in this journal? Yes No See comments sheet
2- Does the publication fit the standard format of the journal? Yes No See comments sheet
3- Is this a new and original contribution? Yes No See comments sheet
4- If a research paper, has this work been published elsewhere? (If so, please provide references to this.) Yes No See comments sheet
5- If a scientific review, is it sufficiently comprehensive and critical? Yes No See comments sheet
6- Is the appendix or attached database (if any) satisfactory? Yes No See comments sheet
7- Is the review of literature suitable and satisfactory? Yes No See comments sheet
8- Does the title clearly and sufficiently reflect the content? Yes No See comments sheet
9- Are the abstract and keywords satisfactory? (If not, please suggest amendments.) Yes No See comments sheet
10- Is the paper of appropriate length? (If not, please suggest alterations.) Yes No See comments sheet
11- Are the data cited following the subject investigated? Yes No See comments sheet
12- Are the applied methods suitable? Yes No See comments sheet
13- Are the applied biomathematical or statistical approaches suitable and satisfactory? Yes No See comments sheet
14- Do the results contain remarkable statements? Yes No See comments sheet
15- Are the interpretations and conclusions sound and justified by the data? Yes No See comments sheet
16- Are the presentation and organization satisfactory? Yes No See comments sheet
17- Are the illustrations and tables necessary and acceptable? Yes No See comments sheet
18- Are the scientific and technical terms correct and accurate? Yes No See comments sheet
19- Is the appropriate reference made to other relevant work? Yes No See comments sheet
20- Is the standard of English satisfactory? Yes No See comments sheet
Section Break
REFEREE’S RECOMMENDATION (Please select only one option)
1- Is the paper accepted for publication in its present form? (Accepted as it stands, although subject to technical editing. Please DO NOT mark this if you have entered ANY significant comments/suggestions on a separate page.) This option is TRUE
2- Is the paper accepted for publication with minor revisions? (Revision required – authors must address the comments or suggestions.) This option is TRUE
3- Is the paper acceptable for publication with major revisions? (Declined in its present form but with an invitation to resubmit.) This option is TRUE
4- Is the paper unacceptable for publication? (Declined for reasons given by the referee.) This option is TRUE
Section Break
Grade the manuscript (choose only one option) 5+ Excellent, top priority. 5 Good, must be published. 4 Acceptable, but with modification by the author. 3 Fair, but not essential, could be returned if there is pressure for space in forthcoming issues. 2 Fair, but repetitive and contributing little, low priority. 1 Not acceptable.
Please select just one option.
Section Break
CONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO THE EDITORS.
Please, send all additional comments regarding this manuscript to southbchem@gmail.com including the title of the manuscript and your name in the massage. You are also welcome to attach any file that you judge necessary to complete the evaluation of the case.
Please provide below any comments you want to the Editors of the Journal. All information you provide here will not be shared with the author(s).

Word: Please type in the word:

SJS SJS Referee report Form

Version beta 01. If you prefer you are welcome to do download and submit the referee report form by e-mail to southbchem@gmail.com.

Section Break

Section Break

Section Break

Section Break

Section Break